Copyright
William St ClairPublished On
2022-05-26ISBN
Language
- English
Print Length
896 pages (xviii+878)Dimensions
Weight
Media
OCLC Number
1099628716LCCN
2021392553BIC
- HBLL
- 1DVG
- 1QDT
BISAC
- ARC005020
- HIS042000
LCC
- DF287.P3
Keywords
- History of the Parthenon
- From the modern era to the present day
- Cultural icon
- National identity
Who Saved the Parthenon?
A New History of the Acropolis Before, During and After the Greek Revolution
- William St Clair (author)
- David St Clair (editor)
- Lucy Barnes (editor)
In this magisterial book, William St Clair unfolds the history of the Parthenon throughout the modern era to the present day, with special emphasis on the period before, during, and after the Greek War of Independence of 1821–32. Focusing particularly on the question of who saved the Parthenon from destruction during this conflict, with the help of documents that shed a new light on this enduring question, he explores the contributions made by the Philhellenes, Ancient Athenians, Ottomans and the Great Powers.
Marshalling a vast amount of primary evidence, much of it previously unexamined and published here for the first time, St Clair rigorously explores the multiple ways in which the Parthenon has served both as a cultural icon onto which meanings are projected and as a symbol of particular national, religious and racial identities, as well as how it illuminates larger questions about the uses of built heritage. This book has a companion volume with the classical Parthenon as its main focus, which offers new ways of recovering the monument and its meanings in ancient times.
St Clair builds on the success of his classic text, The Reading Nation in the Romantic Period, to present this rich and authoritative account of the Parthenon’s presentation and reception throughout history. With weighty implications for the present life of the Parthenon, it is itself a monumental contribution to accounts of the Greek Revolution, to classical studies, and to intellectual history.
Reviews
This rich and rather odd volume is the product of decades of collecting, compiling, and ruminating on the part of the literary scholar and champion of open access publishing, William St. Clair. Sadly, St. Clair died before he could complete manuscript revisions, and thus we owe thanks to his admirable editors, David St. Clair and Lucy Barnes, for weaving together the pieces and making this valuable, if rather anarchic, book available to readers by open access [...] In the end, I am not even sure that St. Clair is particularly pleased that the Parthenon was saved (and he certainly does not seem to like the historically cleansed, Pausanian look of the acropolis today, though he does praise the new acropolis museum for restoring some of the site’s history). In saying that today the built heritage “is at least as influential as words in constituting and changing mentalities,” he goes so far as to suggest that monuments should be seen not as incidental to conflicts, but as among “the causes and the weapons” (658). Was the ‘saving’ of the Parthenon simply a Frankish quest, whose consequences included the sacrificing of many Greek and Turkish lives and the stripping of the monument of the very history that has made it meaningful? Are the Franks the very people from whom the Parthenon has needed saving? This book poses these uncomfortable questions.
Suzanne Marchand
Bryn Mawr Classical Review, 2023.
Additional Resources
All the public domain images in this book have been uploaded to Wikimedia Commons, as William St Clair wished, so that others can use and enjoy them freely.
Contents
Preface
(pp. xiii–xvi)- William St Clair
Why Another Book?
(pp. 1–20)- William St Clair
The Place
(pp. 21–64)- William St Clair
The People
(pp. 65–80)- William St Clair
The Encounter
(pp. 81–140)- William St Clair
Communities, Real and Imagined
(pp. 141–150)- William St Clair
The Evidence
(pp. 151–180)- William St Clair
The New Science and its Enemies
(pp. 181–212)- William St Clair
Towards a Practical Theory of History
(pp. 213–236)- William St Clair
Romanticism and its Rhetorics
(pp. 237–250)- William St Clair
The Choices
(pp. 251–276)- William St Clair
The Siege of 1826 and 1827
(pp. 277–286)- William St Clair
The Surrender
(pp. 287–304)- William St Clair
The Last Days of Ottoman Athens
(pp. 305–314)- William St Clair
The Living
(pp. 315–336)- William St Clair
The Dead
(pp. 337–358)- William St Clair
‘The World had need of them’
(pp. 359–378)- William St Clair
The Secret
(pp. 379–392)- William St Clair
The Bargain
(pp. 393–410)- William St Clair
The Silence
(pp. 411–426)- William St Clair
The Stories
(pp. 427–436)- William St Clair
Which Pasts, which Futures?
(pp. 437–512)- William St Clair
Still a Dark Heritage
(pp. 513–584)- William St Clair
Whose Parthenon?
(pp. 585–624)- William St Clair
The Parthenon in our Time
(pp. 625–654)- William St Clair
Heritage
(pp. 655–660)- William St Clair
- William St Clair
Appendix B: The Firman of 1821
(pp. 679–684)- William St Clair
- William St Clair
- William St Clair
Appendix E: Primary Contemporary Documents Recording the Views of those Who Opposed the Greek Revolution
(pp. 707–730)- William St Clair
- William St Clair
Contributors
William St Clair
(author)(7 December 1937 – 30 June 2021) was a British historian, senior research fellow at the Institute of English Studies, School of Advanced Study, University of London.